Ex parte reexamination is a USPTO proceeding in which a specialized unit of examiners reviews an issued patent’s claims again, using prior art patents and printed publications that raise a substantial new question of patentability. Anyone can file the request, including the patent owner, and the USPTO has granted about 93% of the requests it has decided since 1981. Our team prepares ex parte reexamination requests and defends patents that are on the receiving end of one.
The legal basis is 35 U.S.C. § 302, which lets any person request reexamination of any claim based on cited prior art, explaining how each reference applies to every challenged claim. The USPTO has three months to decide if a substantial new question exists. If it does, the patent goes back into examination until a certificate confirms, amends or cancels the claims.
The sequence resembles ordinary prosecution with one big difference: the requester arrives with references already mapped claim by claim. Having worked on the examining side, we know how differently that reads to an examiner.
Last updated: November 2026
What ex parte reexamination is and who can request it
Ex parte reexamination is a post-grant proceeding handled by the USPTO’s Central Reexamination Unit (CRU), in which an issued patent is examined again against patents and printed publications. Any person can request it, but after the order, the patent owner is the only party who keeps working with the examiner.
Of the 16,022 requests filed through September 30, 2025, third parties filed 73.7% and patent owners 25.2%.
Third-party requesters: anonymity and a short role
A third party can file anonymously through counsel. After the order, the requester can file one reply, and only if the patent owner files a statement first. It receives every office action but cannot interview the examiner, respond to rejections or appeal.
Patent owner requests: testing a patent before enforcement
Owners usually file when they learn of a reference before asserting the patent and want the USPTO to rule on it first. A certificate with confirmed claims makes the patent harder to attack on the same art in court. If the problem is a drafting error, an inventorship mistake or claims that were too narrow, a patent reissue application is the right tool instead.
Who can file, and when:
- Any third party, named or represented anonymously by counsel
- The patent owner, with its own prior art and optional proposed amendments
- The USPTO Director, on the Office’s own initiative
- Any of them at any time during the period of enforceability, which can run past expiration while past damages remain recoverable
Grounds for filing: the substantial new question of patentability
A request succeeds only if it raises a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ), meaning prior art patents or printed publications that a reasonable examiner would consider important in deciding if at least one claim is patentable. The bar is lower than a prima facie rejection. Under MPEP § 2242, the question must also be new: not already decided in an earlier concluded examination or review, not pending in another reexamination, and not the basis of a final court holding of invalidity.
Why only patents and printed publications qualify
The grounds are limited to anticipation and obviousness based on documents. Public use, prior sales, §112 disclosure problems and §101 eligibility fall outside reexamination. Art the original examiner already cited can still qualify if the request presents it in a new light, but merely cumulative art gets denied.
Why reexamination art is often more targeted than prosecution art
An examiner in original prosecution searches classification groups and keywords within a fixed time budget. A requester can spend months on the same question, pulling in product manuals, technical standards, foreign-language patents and theses that an examiner rarely reaches. The request then charts each claim limitation against the matching passage. That preparation explains the grant rate: 14,833 of 15,998 decided requests (92.7%) were granted through September 30, 2025.
The reexamination process from request to certificate
Ex parte reexamination follows a fixed sequence set by statute and USPTO rules, from the filed request to a certificate stating the final status of every claim. As of November 2026, the steps are:
- The requester files the request, fee, claim charts, copies of the art and proof of service on the owner.
- For requests filed on or after April 5, 2026, the owner may file a pre-order paper of up to 30 pages within 30 days of service, at no fee, arguing there is no SNQ. The requester ordinarily cannot respond, per the USPTO’s Official Gazette notice.
- The examiner decides on the SNQ within three months of filing. A denied requester can petition the Director within one month, and most of the fee is refunded.
- After an order, the owner may file an optional statement within two months, with proposed amendments or new claims.
- If the owner filed a statement, the requester may reply within two months of service.
- The examiner issues office actions and the owner responds. The second action is generally final.
- The owner can appeal a final rejection to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, then to the Federal Circuit.
- The proceeding closes with a Notice of Intent to Issue a Reexamination Certificate (NIRC) and the certificate.
How CRU examiners approach reexamination differently from original examination
The CRU works under a statutory duty of special dispatch, so reexaminations move ahead of other work and extensions require sufficient cause. Before each office action, the examiner confers with a panel of at least three members, including a manager, and most conferees had no role in issuing the patent, as MPEP § 2271.01 describes.
In original prosecution, one examiner owns the file and a losing applicant can file a request for continued examination. In the CRU, arguments have to persuade a panel, with no RCE to fall back on. We write reexamination responses for that panel, because a response aimed at a single examiner tends to leave gaps a manager will notice.
Ex parte reexamination vs inter partes review
The core difference is participation. An inter partes review (IPR) is a trial before Patent Trial and Appeal Board judges in which the challenger litigates to a final written decision, while in ex parte reexamination the challenger steps aside once the request is filed.
| Factor | Ex parte reexamination | Inter partes review |
|---|---|---|
| Who can file | Anyone, including the patent owner | Third parties only |
| Challenger’s role after filing | Request, plus one reply if the owner files a statement | Full participation through the final decision |
| Threshold | Substantial new question of patentability | Reasonable likelihood of prevailing on one claim |
| Filing deadline | Any time during enforceability | One year after service of an infringement complaint |
| Anonymity | Available | Real party in interest must be named |
| Estoppel against the challenger | None from the reexamination itself | Applies in later USPTO, court and ITC proceedings |
| USPTO fees (large entity) | $6,775 or $13,545 | $23,750 plus $28,125 after institution, up to 20 claims |
Requests have climbed as IPR institution became harder to predict, reaching 491 in fiscal year 2025, the highest annual total since 2012. A December 2025 Federal Circuit decision involving Gesture Technology Partners also held that IPR estoppel does not stop a reexamination already pending, and that the USPTO keeps jurisdiction over expired patents.
Patent owners comparing their own repair options can read our breakdown of patent reissue vs reexamination.
Patent owner rights during reexamination
After the order, the patent owner holds almost every procedural right in the proceeding, and our reexamination prosecution work focuses on using them early. The owner can:
- File a pre-order paper within 30 days of service, for requests filed on or after April 5, 2026
- File a patent owner statement with proposed amendments or new claims
- Request examiner interviews, which the requester cannot do
- Respond to every office action with evidence such as expert declarations
- Appeal an adverse final decision to the PTAB and the Federal Circuit
The statement is optional, and many owners skip it because filing one gives the requester a reply.
Most rejections are anticipation or obviousness rejections built from the request’s claim charts. Our guide on how to respond to a 35 USC 103 rejection covers argument and evidence strategies that carry over.
Amendments and intervening rights
Under 35 U.S.C. § 305, no amended or new claim may enlarge the scope of the original claims. Narrowing amendments create intervening rights, which can shield a party that made or sold an accused product before the certificate issued. That is why owners argue before they amend, and why “claims changed” is still the most common result: 68.4% of owner-requested certificates and 61.0% of third-party-requested certificates through September 30, 2025.
Timeline, cost, and what USPTO data shows
Expect roughly a year and a half to two years from request to certificate, USPTO filing fees of $6,775 or $13,545 for a large entity, and attorney fees driven by the number of claims, references and declarations. Per the USPTO fee schedule as of November 2026:
| USPTO fee | Large entity | Small entity | Micro entity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Request, streamlined (40 pages or fewer) | $6,775 | $2,710 | $1,355 |
| Request, non-streamlined | $13,545 | $5,418 | $2,709 |
| Notice of appeal | $905 | $362 | $181 |
| Forwarding an appeal to the Board | $2,535 | $1,014 | $507 |
| Petitions in a reexamination proceeding | $2,195 | $878 | $439 |
Third-party requesters are not eligible for micro entity fees. Our professional fees run $15,000 to $50,000 to prepare and file a request and $10,000 to $30,000 to prosecute a reexamination for the patent owner, depending on claims challenged, references charted and any declarations or appeal.
The USPTO’s ex parte reexamination statistics through September 30, 2025 show an average pendency of 25.2 months and a median of 18.9 months from filing to certificate. Of 13,126 certificates issued since 1981:
- All claims confirmed in 22.2% overall, 22.9% of third-party requests and 21.3% of owner requests
- All claims canceled in 14.5% overall, 16.1% of third-party requests and 10.3% of owner requests
- Claims changed in 63.3% overall, 61.0% of third-party requests and 68.4% of owner requests
- Patents known to be in litigation in 40.5% of reexaminations
Only about one in six third-party reexaminations cancels every claim, but most end with changed claims that can create intervening rights.
When to request reexamination and when to defend
Request reexamination when your best art is documentary and you want a lower-cost challenge without estoppel. A request is only as strong as its art, so a targeted prior art search usually comes first. Filing tends to make sense when:
- The strongest references are patents or printed publications, not prior sales or public use
- The one-year IPR deadline has passed, or an IPR petition was denied on discretionary grounds
- The requester wants to stay anonymous
- The company wants its invalidity arguments open in district court
- The budget does not support a full PTAB trial
It is a weaker fit when the case depends on §112 or §101 arguments, or when a narrowly amended claim would still cover the challenger’s product.
A patent owner served with a request should calendar the 30-day pre-order deadline immediately, because it cannot be extended. Then decide which claims carry commercial value, if the charts misread the art and what any amendment would cost in intervening rights.
What patent owners and challengers ask us about reexamination
USPTO data through September 30, 2025 shows an average of 25.2 months and a median of 18.9 months from filing to certificate. The decision on the substantial new question comes within three months of filing by statute. Proceedings without an appeal close faster, while an appeal to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board can add a year or more. Special dispatch keeps reexaminations ahead of ordinary examination work at the CRU.
Only in a limited way. After reexamination is ordered, a third-party requester can file one reply, and only if the patent owner filed a statement first. The requester receives copies of every office action but cannot respond, interview the examiner or appeal. Since April 2026, it also generally cannot answer the owner’s pre-order paper, so the original request is its main chance to shape the outcome.
It is the threshold the USPTO applies before ordering reexamination. A prior art patent or printed publication raises one when a reasonable examiner would consider it important in deciding if at least one claim is patentable, and the Office or a final court ruling has not already decided the same question. The request does not need to prove unpatentability, and previously cited art can qualify when presented in a new light.
Yes. A request can be filed at any time during the period of enforceability, which continues after expiration while the owner can still recover damages for past infringement. The Federal Circuit confirmed in December 2025 that the USPTO keeps jurisdiction over expired patents in ex parte reexamination. Expired claims cannot be amended, so the owner has to defend them as issued, relying on argument and evidence.
The reexamination creates no estoppel against the requester, who can still raise the same art in district court. Estoppel can run the other way. A party that received a final written decision in an IPR or post-grant review cannot file a new request on grounds it raised or reasonably could have raised there. Under the December 2025 Federal Circuit ruling, that estoppel does not end a reexamination already pending.
Yes, with limits. The owner can propose amended or new claims in the patent owner statement and in responses to office actions, as long as no claim becomes broader than the original and the disclosure supports the change. Narrowing a claim can create intervening rights for parties who made or sold accused products before the certificate issued, so we weigh each amendment against what it could cost in enforcement value.
Choosing your side of the reexamination
Ex parte reexamination rewards preparation done before the USPTO looks at the patent. For a requester that means charts a panel will find convincing; for a patent owner it means treating the first 30 days after service as the window that can stop the order.
IP Boutique Law is a patent and intellectual property firm in Washington, D.C. with 25+ years of USPTO examiner experience. Our team handles patent drafting, prosecution, trademark registration, design patents, provisional applications, ex parte reexamination, and patent reissue across chemical, biochemical, electrical, and mechanical fields. We serve inventors and companies in the U.S. and internationally, bringing insider examiner knowledge to every stage of the patent process.
If you are weighing a request or have just been served with one, let’s review the art and the claims together before the first deadline runs. You can contact our team, call +1 202 773 9579 or write to contact@ipboutiquelaw.com.
Reviewed by Carlos López, patent attorney and former USPTO examiner with 25+ years of IP experience.

