Ex parte reexamination prosecution gives a patent owner one real round to argue and amend before the Central Reexamination Unit (CRU) closes the record. The second office action is generally final and the rules offer no request for continued examination, so the first response decides most cases. Our ex parte reexamination prosecution work starts from that constraint, and every argument, declaration and fallback claim goes into that first response.
The statute sets the boundaries. Under 35 U.S.C. § 305, the patent owner can propose amendments and new claims to distinguish the cited prior art, but no amendment may enlarge the scope of an existing claim. The whole proceeding, including any appeal, runs with special dispatch, which means shorter deadlines than in original prosecution.
Having worked inside the USPTO, we read reexamination the way the panel reviewing it does. The examiners deciding your case did not issue the patent, they review each action as a group, and they respond to technical evidence far more than to advocacy.
Last updated: November 2026
What changes when a CRU panel examines your patent
Reexamination follows the procedures of initial examination, but every substantive action the CRU issues passes through a panel before it reaches you. Per MPEP 2271, a panel of three or more members, including a manager, reviews the examiner’s preliminary decision at each stage, and most members should not have examined or issued the patent. A primary examiner signs the final action. From the examiner’s side of the desk, that changes the review. A single art unit examiner may carry assumptions from the first search, while a panel tests each rejection against the record and asks whether the owner’s answer is supported.
Claim construction can also shift. For an unexpired patent, the CRU applies the broadest reasonable interpretation. Once the patent expires, the examiner applies the Phillips standard courts use, because the owner can no longer amend, and a construction argument that failed under the broader standard can become persuasive.
| Factor | Original prosecution | Reexamination prosecution |
|---|---|---|
| Who examines | One examiner in an art unit | CRU examiner, with panel review of each action |
| Prior art basis | Any prior art the examiner finds | Patents and printed publications raising a substantial new question |
| Continuing options | RCE and continuation applications | No RCE and no refiling |
| Claim scope changes | Broader claims allowed before grant | No enlarging of any existing claim |
| Response periods | Up to six months with extension fees | Normally two months, limited extensions |
| Third-party role | None | Requester cannot attend interviews or answer office action responses |
Reexamination prosecution process, step by step
Reexamination prosecution runs on a fixed sequence, and the owner’s options shrink at each stage. For third-party requests filed on or after April 5, 2026, it looks like this.
- Within 30 days of service of the request, with no extension, the owner may file a pre-order paper of up to 30 pages arguing that no substantial new question of patentability (SNQ) exists.
- The CRU decides whether to order reexamination within three months of the filing date.
- After an order, the owner may file a patent owner statement, with or without amendments, in the period the order sets (at least two months), or file a waiver.
- If a statement is filed, the requester has two months from service to reply.
- The examiner issues the first office action, and the owner responds, normally within two months.
- The second action is generally final.
- The owner requests reconsideration or proposes after-final amendments, receives an advisory action and decides whether to appeal.
- The office issues a Notice of Intent to Issue a Reexamination Certificate (NIRC), then the certificate confirming, amending or canceling claims.
Our complete guide to ex parte reexamination covers the SNQ standard and the pre-order paper in detail. For the defense, arguments that the cited art is cumulative belong in the early papers, while office action responses focus on patentability over the art as applied.
Patent owner statement and response strategy
In most defenses, we recommend waiving or limiting the patent owner statement and building the first office action response as if it were the only one, because procedurally it nearly is.
Filing the statement or waiving it
The statement under 37 CFR 1.530 lets the owner argue patentability and propose amendments before the first action. It also opens a two-month window for the requester to reply, the requester’s last chance to speak on the merits. We file one only when an early amendment would remove a likely rejection, and otherwise serve a waiver so the case moves forward.
Front-loading the first office action response
Expert declarations, claim charts, new claims at several scope levels and an answer to every ground of rejection go into the first response at once. After a final action, the owner has no right to amend or add evidence, and entry of anything new is at the examiner’s discretion.
The response structure is the one described in our guide on how to respond to a patent office action. The difference in reexamination is the margin for error, since a missed deadline terminates prosecution and the certificate follows the last action, which can mean canceled claims.
Arguments that work in reexamination after failing in original prosecution
Some arguments an art unit examiner rejected years ago get a different reception at the CRU.
- Objective evidence that did not exist at filing. Commercial success, licensing, industry praise and copying often accumulate after issuance. Presented through declarations under 37 CFR 1.132 with a clear nexus to the claimed features, this evidence can rebut obviousness where the original record could not.
- Technical declarations on why a skilled person would not combine the references. The requester has no right to answer the owner’s office action responses, so a well-supported declaration often stands unrebutted.
- Claim construction tied to specific passages of the specification, which a panel reading the record fresh weighs more heavily than arguments from claim language alone.
Attorney argument without evidence rarely works. Having examined those papers from the other side of the desk, we know how quickly a panel sets them aside.
Claim amendment options and limitations
Amendments in reexamination can narrow claims, cancel them or add new claims without a fixed limit, as long as no claim becomes broader than the original claims and no new matter enters. Owners who need broader coverage have a different route, a reissue application, which allows broadening only if filed within two years of grant.
MPEP 2250 adds formatting rules that often trip up practitioners used to original prosecution.
- Brackets and underlining show changes relative to the original patent, not to the previous amendment.
- Every amendment lists the status of all claims and explains the support for each change.
- Patent claims are never renumbered, and new claims start after the highest-numbered patent claim.
- Amendments take effect only when the certificate issues, and an expired patent allows only cancellation.
Intervening rights
Under 35 U.S.C. § 307(b), a claim amended or added in reexamination has the same effect as a reissued claim under section 252. Anyone who made, used, sold or imported the product before the certificate issued, or made substantial preparations to do so, may hold intervening rights, and pre-certificate damages can be lost for claims that changed in substance. That is why we argue the original claims first whenever the evidence supports them and add narrower claims as fallbacks.
Prosecution history estoppel specific to reexamination
Everything filed in reexamination becomes part of the prosecution history. The Federal Circuit has applied prosecution disclaimer to statements made during reexamination where the owner clearly and unmistakably disavowed a meaning to overcome the art, and narrowing amendments can restrict the range of equivalents.
The risk is sharper because reexamination usually runs alongside an infringement case, where a narrow reading of a claim term can become the accused infringer’s best defense. We coordinate with trial counsel before filing anything that characterizes claim scope.
Interview procedures in reexamination
Patent owners can request interviews in reexamination, and the requester cannot attend. Interviews on patentability generally happen only after the first office action, under the procedure in MPEP 2281.
- Contact the examiner to identify the issues and confirm an interview will be granted.
- File an informal statement of the issues and any proposed claims at least three working days before, unless waived.
- Hold the interview, limited to one hour unless extended, normally one per office action.
- File a complete written statement of the reasons presented, with the response or within one month of the interview, whichever is later.
The last step is mandatory under 37 CFR 1.560(b), and missing it terminates the reexamination prosecution. An interview is most useful for testing which fallback claim the panel is likely to accept before it goes into the response.
When reexamination goes wrong: after-final and appeal options
A final rejection narrows the owner’s options without ending the defense. Only the patent owner can appeal in ex parte reexamination (35 U.S.C. § 306). If new prior art surfaces outside the current proceeding, the owner can also consider filing its own reexamination request to address that art on the owner’s terms.
- Respond within the period set, requesting reconsideration or proposing amendments such as canceling claims. Entry is discretionary under 37 CFR 1.116.
- Review the advisory action, which states whether the response was entered.
- File a notice of appeal to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board and, within two months, an appeal brief answering every ground of rejection.
- To dispute the SNQ itself, request reconsideration from the examiner first, then raise it under a separate heading of the brief, per MPEP 2274.
- If the Board affirms, appeal to the Federal Circuit.
A missed brief deadline leads to dismissal and a NIRC on the record as it stands. These are the USPTO fees an owner may pay during prosecution and appeal, per the USPTO fee schedule as of November 2026.
| USPTO fee | Large entity | Small entity | Micro entity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Each independent claim over three (37 CFR 1.20(c)(3)) | $600 | $240 | $120 |
| Each claim over 20 (37 CFR 1.20(c)(4)) | $200 | $80 | $40 |
| Notice of appeal (37 CFR 41.20(b)(1)) | $905 | $362 | $181 |
| Forwarding an appeal to the Board (37 CFR 41.20(b)(4)) | $2,535 | $1,014 | $507 |
| Request for oral hearing (37 CFR 41.20(b)(3)) | $1,460 | $584 | $292 |
Timeline expectations for the patent owner
Most of the owner’s work happens within a few months of the order, even though USPTO statistics through September 30, 2025 put average pendency from filing to certificate at 25.2 months, with a median of 18.9 months. As of November 2026, these are the periods that drive the owner’s calendar.
- Pre-order paper, 30 days from service, with no extension.
- Patent owner statement, at least two months from the order.
- Each office action response, normally two months.
- After a final action, a timely first response counts as a request for two more months, up to six months from the final action.
Extensions fall under 37 CFR 1.550(c), since the general extension rules of original prosecution do not apply. In third-party-requested cases, which describe most defenses, extensions require sufficient cause and are usually limited to one month, so expert declarations should be in preparation before the first action arrives.
Our attorney fees for ex parte reexamination prosecution range from $10,000 to $30,000, depending on the number of claims, the technology and how many office actions the case requires.
Defending a patent in reexamination: what owners ask first
Yes. The owner can add new claims in a patent owner statement or an office action response, with no fixed limit on the number, as long as no new claim is broader than the patent’s original claims and every claim finds support in the original disclosure. Claims beyond three independent or twenty total carry excess-claim fees. Added claims take effect only when the certificate issues, and they can give rise to intervening rights for others.
No. Reexamination does not allow a request for continued examination or a refiled proceeding, so the second office action is generally the final one. After a final rejection, the owner can request reconsideration, propose amendments the examiner may or may not enter, and appeal to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. That is why we build the first response with every argument, declaration and fallback claim the case needs.
Only in a limited way. The requester receives copies of office actions and the owner’s papers, and it may reply once if the owner files a patent owner statement. It cannot attend interviews, cannot comment on the owner’s office action responses and has no right to appeal. Under the April 2026 procedure, a requester may answer a pre-order paper only by petition, with a fee and a ten-page limit.
Yes. The reexamination record becomes part of the patent’s prosecution history, and courts have applied prosecution disclaimer to clear statements a patent owner made during reexamination to distinguish prior art. Narrowing amendments can also limit equivalents. Because reexaminations often run in parallel with infringement cases, we review every characterization of claim scope against the litigation position before it is filed with the Central Reexamination Unit.
The owner still has options. A response after final can request reconsideration or propose amendments, and the examiner issues an advisory action stating whether it was entered. If the rejections stand, the owner can appeal to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board and then to the Federal Circuit. If the owner takes no action, the office issues a certificate canceling the rejected claims, which is the outcome an appeal exists to prevent.
Preparing your reexamination defense
A reexamination defense is decided mostly by the first response, filed before a panel that reads the record fresh. The decision with the longest consequences often comes earlier, in the 30 days after service, when the owner decides on a pre-order paper and starts building the declarations the first response will need.
IP Boutique Law is a patent and intellectual property firm in Washington, D.C. with 25+ years of USPTO examiner experience. Our team handles patent drafting, prosecution, trademark registration, design patents, provisional applications, ex parte reexamination, and patent reissue across chemical, biochemical, electrical, and mechanical fields. We serve inventors and companies in the U.S. and internationally, bringing insider examiner knowledge to every stage of the patent process.
If your patent has been ordered into reexamination, or a request has just been served, our team can review the request, the cited art and the original prosecution history with you before the first deadline. Call us at +1 202 773 9579, email contact@ipboutiquelaw.com, or schedule a consultation so we can map out the defense together.
Reviewed by Carlos López, patent attorney and former USPTO examiner with 25+ years of IP experience.

