The USPTO has ordered 92.7% of decided ex parte reexamination requests since 1981, but that figure measures access to the proceeding, not who wins it. At the end of the process, only 22.9% of certificates in third-party reexaminations confirmed every claim unchanged, 16.1% canceled all claims, and 61.0% changed the claims in some way. Anyone weighing an ex parte reexamination request needs to read both numbers together, because they answer different questions.
These figures come from the USPTO’s Ex Parte Reexamination Filing Data report, current through September 30, 2025. It covers 16,022 requests and 13,126 issued certificates, with an average pendency of 25.2 months from filing to certificate and a median of 18.9 months.
From the examiner’s side of the desk, an order only means the request raised a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ). Once the Central Reexamination Unit (CRU) orders the proceeding, the patent owner is the party who argues, amends and interviews with the examiner, and that asymmetry is why the raw grant rate overstates a requester’s odds.
Last updated: November 2026
What the USPTO certificate data shows
Most ex parte reexaminations end with amended or new claims, about one in five confirms every claim, and full cancellation is the least common result. The pattern holds whether the patent owner or a third party filed the request, with harsher results when a third party files.
| Certificate outcome | Third-party requester | Patent owner requester | Commissioner initiated |
|---|---|---|---|
| All claims confirmed | 2,043 (22.9%) | 859 (21.3%) | 17 (9.8%) |
| All claims canceled | 1,439 (16.1%) | 413 (10.3%) | 46 (26.4%) |
| Claims changed | 5,445 (61.0%) | 2,753 (68.4%) | 111 (63.8%) |
| Total certificates | 8,927 | 4,025 | 174 |
Source: USPTO Ex Parte Reexamination Filing Data, September 30, 2025, section 10.
Patent owners who request reexamination of their own patent see fewer total cancellations, 10.3% against 16.1%. The gap makes sense once you know who picks the art. An owner tests the patent against references it expects to beat, while a third party files with the strongest art it could find.
Grant rate vs outcome rate: two numbers people confuse
The grant rate tells you how often the CRU opens a proceeding. A requester’s realistic odds come from combining it with the certificate outcomes, in three steps.
- Start with the order rate, 92.7% historically and lower in 2026.
- Apply the share of third-party certificates that canceled or changed at least some claims, which is 77.1%.
- Multiply the two, which gives roughly 71.5% of filed third-party requests ending with some change to the patent.
That 71.5% is a ceiling, because a certificate counts as “changed” even when the claims you care about came through intact.
What “claims changed” hides
The changed category groups together amended claims, the cancellation of some claims, and new claims added by the owner. A certificate that adds ten new dependent claims and leaves the asserted claims untouched counts the same as one that rewrites claim 1 into something no product infringes.
The report also invites a misreading. Section 8 shows each outcome as a share of all certificates, so third-party “claims changed” appears there as 41%, while section 10 shows the same group at 61.0% of its own certificates.
What “success” means for requesters and for patent owners
Success in reexamination has two definitions, and each side can claim a win from the same certificate. A requester usually wins when the asserted claims are canceled or narrowed. A patent owner usually wins when a claim that still reads on the accused product survives.
For a requester, a successful outcome tends to look like one of these.
- Cancellation of the claims asserted in litigation or licensing demands
- Narrowing amendments that trigger intervening rights under 35 U.S.C. § 307(b), which applies the reissue rule of § 252 to amended and new claims and protects activity that began before the certificate issued
- Statements by the owner in the reexamination file that limit how a court later reads the claims
For a patent owner, success usually means one of three things. The asserted claims come out confirmed. Amended claims still cover the accused product, even if intervening rights cut back past damages. Or new claims read on competing products going forward.
A certificate records what happened to each claim, not which side had the better result, so both sides publish “wins” from the same data. Fix your definition before you file or respond, because it decides which claims you fight to keep.
How the 2025-2026 changes are moving the numbers
The historical 92.7% order rate no longer describes current practice. Filings rose sharply once inter partes review (IPR) institution at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) became harder to obtain, and since April 2026 patent owners can argue against an order before the CRU decides.
The USPTO report shows annual filings rising from 288 in fiscal year 2023 to 417 in 2024 and 491 in 2025. Bloomberg Law, citing ExamPat data, reported 1,644 requests in fiscal year 2026 through June, more than three times the 2025 total.
The USPTO answered with an Official Gazette notice creating the pre-order paper. For requests filed on or after April 5, 2026, the patent owner may file a paper of up to 30 pages within 30 days of service, with no fee or petition, arguing that the request raises no SNQ. A requester can respond only by petition under 37 CFR 1.182.
An IPWatchdog analysis by Adam Wichman, published November 2, 2026 and based on USPTO Open Data, tracked the order rate across three periods.
- 2023 to 2025, 96.4% of requests ordered
- January 1 to April 4, 2026, 88.5%
- April 5 to October 22, 2026, 84.1% (292 of 347 decided requests)
Patent owners filed a pre-order paper in 39% of requests since April 5. The order rate was 82.4% with a paper and 85.6% without one, a gap the analysis found not statistically significant. Our reading is that volume and weaker requests explain more of the drop than owner papers do, and the quality of the request is still the variable a requester controls. For the full procedure from request to certificate, see our ex parte reexamination guide.
Factors examiners associate with claims surviving reexamination
Claims survive reexamination when the cited art adds little to what the original examiner considered, when the owner has dependent claims ready as fallbacks, and when amendments and evidence arrive before the record closes. Our reexamination prosecution work centers on those points, because the CRU gives an owner fewer chances to recover.
These are the factors we see decide outcomes.
- Whether the art is new. A request that recycles references the original examiner already weighed gives the CRU little reason to reach a different conclusion.
- How the claims are construed. For an unexpired patent, the CRU reads claims under their broadest reasonable interpretation, so terms the owner considered narrow can reach more art than they would in court.
- The depth of the dependent claims. Layered dependent claims give the owner amendment options that keep commercially relevant scope.
- When the amendments arrive. Under 35 U.S.C. § 305, no amendment or new claim may enlarge the scope of the patent, and amendments filed after a final rejection face limited entry, so the first response is where narrowing options belong.
- Use of the examiner interview. MPEP 2281 allows interviews only with the patent owner or its practitioner, and the owner must file a written statement of the reasons for favorable action within one month of the interview or with the response. Missing that statement terminates the reexamination prosecution.
- Evidence beyond argument. Declarations on technical meaning or secondary considerations carry weight that attorney argument alone does not.
Examiners respond to record evidence. A response that cites the references line by line to show the combination fails moves a rejection, and one built on confident characterization rarely does. Having worked on the examiner’s side, we know which kind changes minds.
Why patent owner representation quality changes the outcome
The USPTO does not publish reexamination outcomes split by whether the patent owner had counsel, and we have not found a study that does. Two facts frame the comparison anyway.
Under 37 CFR 1.31, a juristic entity such as a corporate assignee, and any patent owner domiciled outside the United States, must act through a registered patent practitioner. As a result, most owners in reexamination already have counsel. The real comparison is between counsel who know CRU practice and counsel who treat reexamination like ordinary prosecution.
The closest published data comes from original prosecution. A 2012 PLOS ONE study by Kate Gaudry compared 250 pro se applications with 250 represented ones.
| Measure (original prosecution) | Pro se applicants | Represented applicants |
|---|---|---|
| Applications abandoned | About 76% | About 35% |
| Responded to the first Office action | About 41% | About 86% |
| Claim clarity rejection in the first action | About 65% | About 27% |
Reexamination compresses those risks into a shorter window. There is no continuation to fall back on, claims cannot be broadened, and any claim the owner fails to save is canceled on the certificate.
Strategic implications: request, defend, or wait
The data favors requesters who bring new art and a clear SNQ, and it favors owners who respond early with fallback claims. On either side the decision rests on the quality of the art, which is why most strong requests start with a validity-focused prior art search.
If you are the requester, work through these steps before filing.
- Search for references the original examiner never cited, and drop art that only repeats what is already in the file history.
- Chart each asserted claim limitation against the references, with a separate SNQ for each combination.
- Assume the owner will file a pre-order paper, and address the likely SNQ objections inside the request, since a reply requires a petition that is usually refused.
- Budget for fees. The USPTO fee schedule lists $13,545 for a non-streamlined request and $6,775 for a streamlined one at the undiscounted rate, and third-party requesters cannot use micro entity fees. Our request work runs $15,000 to $50,000, depending on the art and the number of claims.
If you are the patent owner, the priorities shift:
- Calendar the 30-day pre-order window from the date the request is served, and decide quickly whether a paper is worth filing.
- Audit the dependent claims and draft amendment options before the first Office action. Our guide on when to narrow and when to argue covers the trade-offs.
- Decide early whether accepting intervening rights on amended claims is worth keeping enforceable claims against future infringers.
- Plan for prosecution costs, which run $10,000 to $30,000 with our firm.
Reexamination odds: what owners and challengers ask before they commit
Through September 30, 2025, the USPTO granted 92.7% of decided requests since the procedure began in 1981. The rate has fallen in 2026. An IPWatchdog analysis of USPTO data found 84.1% of requests ordered between April 5 and October 22, 2026, compared with 96.4% across 2023 to 2025. A strong SNQ built on art the original examiner never considered remains the best predictor that a request will be ordered.
Full cancellation is the least common outcome. Across 13,126 certificates issued through September 2025, 14.5% canceled every claim. The rate is 16.1% when a third party filed the request and 10.3% when the patent owner did. Most certificates, 63.3% overall, end with changed claims, which can mean amended claims, some claims canceled, or new claims added by the owner during the proceeding.
The two are hard to compare directly. Reexamination has a higher order rate, but the requester drops out after filing and the patent owner can amend and interview with the examiner alone. IPR is adversarial and allows discovery and a hearing, but institution has become much harder to obtain since 2025. The right choice depends on your art, your estoppel exposure under IPR, and your litigation timeline.
Yes, for requests filed on or after April 5, 2026. The patent owner may file a pre-order paper of up to 30 pages within 30 days of service, arguing that the request raises no substantial new question of patentability. So far the effect looks modest. Requests with a pre-order paper were ordered 82.4% of the time, against 85.6% without one, a difference the analysis found not statistically significant.
The USPTO reports an average pendency of 25.2 months from filing to certificate, with a median of 18.9 months, based on data through September 30, 2025. Those figures predate the 2026 surge in filings. With far more requests pending at the Central Reexamination Unit, we expect pendency for new requests to run longer, and an appeal to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board adds more time.
It can. Under 35 U.S.C. § 307(b), amended or new claims that emerge from reexamination carry the intervening rights rules of reissue under § 252. Anyone who made, used, sold or imported the product, or made substantial preparations to do so, before the certificate issued may keep certain rights against those claims. Original claims confirmed without amendment are not subject to intervening rights, which is why owners fight to keep them unchanged.
Reading the odds before you file or respond
A 92.7% grant rate gets a request through the door, but the certificate decides the result, and fewer than one in four third-party proceedings ends with every claim confirmed. For requesters, the art and the SNQ framing decide most of what happens. For owners, the first response and the fallback claims ready behind it decide whether the patent keeps commercial value.
IP Boutique Law is a patent and intellectual property firm in Washington, D.C. with 25+ years of USPTO examiner experience. Our team handles patent drafting, prosecution, trademark registration, design patents, provisional applications, ex parte reexamination, and patent reissue across chemical, biochemical, electrical, and mechanical fields. We serve inventors and companies in the U.S. and internationally, bringing insider examiner knowledge to every stage of the patent process.
If you are weighing a reexamination request or have just been served with one, we can review the art and the claims with you and give you a sincere assessment. Call us at +1 202 773 9579, email contact@ipboutiquelaw.com, or schedule a consultation so we can work through it together.
Reviewed by Carlos López, patent attorney and former USPTO examiner with 25+ years of IP experience.

